Can You Afford a Nanny? Costs and Considerations

Deciding to hire outside help for childcare can be overwhelming. You want someone you can trust, who will provide quality care during their shift, and it's natural to worry about the costs. Suppose this is something you're currently considering. In that case, we understand how difficult it can be to weigh the options and questions that arise as you decide whether hiring a nanny is suitable for your family. In this article, we will explore different types of nannies available, what they cost on average, essential things to consider when choosing one, and other helpful tips so you can make an informed decision that works best for your household.

What is The Cost of Nanny?


​​When hiring a nanny, it's important to remember that their salaries must be covered under the Fair Labor Standards Act. This means that nannies must be paid at least the federal minimum wage. However, many caregivers charge a higher hourly rate than the minimum wage due to the level of responsibility involved in caring for a baby. Remembering that each state has minimum wage requirements for nannies is also crucial. Additionally, nannies may receive overtime pay if they work more than 40 hours a week. To ensure that both the nanny and baby are well taken care of, following these legal requirements and paying your nanny a fair wage is essential.


Parents looking to hire a nanny should remember that the average hourly rate for a nanny is approximately $17 per hour. However, this rate can shift considerably depending on a variety of factors. One significant factor is the nanny's level of education, as those with advanced degrees or specialized training in working with babies may command higher rates. Additionally, geographic location, years of experience, certifications in CPR and first aid, and specialties like newborn care or lactation consulting can all play a role in the final cost. Finally, the number of children the nanny would be caring for and any additional responsibilities like travel will also impact the overall hourly rate. With all of these factors in play, it's essential for parents to carefully evaluate their options and choose a nanny who can offer the best possible care for their baby.


Living in areas with a higher cost can mean spending a little more, especially for parents looking for quality care for their babies. For instance, parents in New York City pay an average of $22. However, it is essential to consider the additional costs of hiring a nanny for your little one. Along with the hourly rate, parents must also consider transportation costs for the nanny, health insurance and payroll taxes (if paying on the books), vacation and paid time off, holiday bonuses and gifts, potential overtime costs, and annual raises. When planning for these extra expenditures, parents can ensure that their baby's well-being is taken care of without worrying about any financial surprises.


Related Link: 10 Best Baby Lotions: Protect Your Baby's Skin

Nanny with boy

Live-in Nanny

When considering hiring a full-time nanny, it's essential to understand that a live-in nanny may have a slightly lower salary than a live-out nanny. This is because as an employer, you are also providing room and board for the nanny. However, it's important to note that hiring a live-in nanny can be more cost-effective as they typically work longer hours daily. Regardless of the type of nanny you choose, having an extra set of hands to help with your baby can be a priceless investment.

Part-time Nanny

When searching for a part-time nanny, one must consider their years of experience, education, and certifications. These factors can contribute to their hourly rates, which are often similar to those of full-time nannies. Families paying their nannies more than $1,900 per year may need to deal with the nanny tax. However, some families pay their nanny in cash to avoid these taxes. Regardless of the payment method, finding the right nanny can be a crucial decision for parents. Whether you need help during the workday or just a few hours here and there, a reliable and experienced nanny can provide the care and attention your baby needs to thrive.

Have any questions about how to take care of your baby? Check out 123 Baby Box today!

Cost of Nanny With More Than One Child

When hiring a nanny to care for your children, it's important to remember that having more than one child often comes with a higher cost. Families who hire a nanny pay around $1-3 more per hour than they would for a nanny to watch an only child. However, it's essential to remember that this rate can vary depending on where you live. While the cost may be higher, having a nanny who can care for multiple children at once can be a game-changer for busy parents.

Factors to Consider When Paying A Nanny

The Nanny Tax

As a new parent, the last thing you want to worry about is taxes. However, if you hire a nanny to take care of your baby, the "Nanny Tax" is something that you need to be aware of. It's important to remember that your nanny is a household team member, and taxes need to be deducted from their salary. This includes withholding Medicare, Social Security, and federal and state income taxes. Additionally, you must pay the employer's Social Security and federal and state unemployment taxes. While the tax requirements may differ depending on where you live, it's essential to familiarize yourself with the rules to avoid any surprises come tax season. Check out Care.com’s state tax requirements page for more information.

Paid Vacation and Holidays

Paid vacation is an essential benefit offered to nannies to show appreciation for their hard work and dedication. As a caregiver responsible for the safety and well-being of someone's child, it is essential to take time off to recharge and rejuvenate. Typically, nannies receive two weeks of paid vacation, which can be scheduled to coincide with other school vacations, making it easier for both parties. 


Most nannies receive around six paid holidays, which is a great way to ensure you get time to rest and recharge. These holidays usually include New Year's Day, Memorial Day, 4th of July, Labor Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, and some federal holidays. By providing paid holidays to their nannies, families acknowledge the hard work of caring for their little ones 24/7 and understand the importance of giving their caretakers a break. With these paid holidays, nannies can take some time to relax, spend time with friends and family, and come back to work rejuvenated and ready to continue providing excellent care for the babies they love.


Do you still want to know more about how to care for your baby? Visit our blog to find the answers you need.

Caretaker holding baby’s hand

Sick Days

Paid sick days can be an essential benefit for those who work closely with children, especially babies. While it may not be as common as paid vacation or holidays, it is comforting to know that about 67% of employers offer this benefit. 


Related Link: 5 Best Baby Formulas: Know What you Feed Your Baby

Health Insurance

When hiring a nanny, the cost goes beyond just their hourly rate or yearly salary. Parents also need to consider other expenses, such as insurance. Depending on where you live and the type of insurance chosen, the costs can add up to $200-300 per month. It's essential to make sure that your nanny has access to adequate health insurance coverage, as this can make all the difference in ensuring the well-being of your baby. After all, nothing is more important than the health and safety of your little one.

Reimbursement for Transportation

Regarding transportation reimbursement or supplement for your nanny, you must consider where you live and the types of transportation your nanny uses. For those living in bustling cities like New York City, providing a monthly unlimited MetroCard for your nanny can be a practical solution for their daily commute to work. On the other hand, if your nanny uses a car to run errands or take your baby to school, it's standard practice to reimburse them for gas and tolls. Remember, ensuring your nanny has reliable transportation can not only benefit their commute but also contribute to the safety and well-being of your baby.

Annual Raises

As a parent, it is essential to recognize the importance of your nanny and tangibly show your appreciation. Don't forget to give your nanny an annual raise, ranging from 3-10%. A raise acknowledges the hard work and dedication your nanny puts into caring for your baby and helps retain top talent in the childcare industry. When considering the raise amount, it is essential to factor in both cost-of-living increases and merit. Your nanny is an integral part of your family, so show them how much you value their role by providing a fair and consistent raise each year.

Deciding on A Nanny

It is essential to take the time to consider all of the options available when considering hiring a nanny for childcare needs. The financial cost is an essential factor in determining what type of childcare is most appropriate for each family's budget and needs. Every family's situation and financial situation is different, so there is no one-size-fits-all solution; it's essential to do your research and make an educated decision when deciding if a nanny is the right option for your family. Depending on the level of care needed, nannies may be more expensive than other forms of child care but may also provide more personalized attention. Before making any decisions, families should weigh all their options and consider any additional costs that might be associated with bringing someone into their home to help with the children's daily routines.


Related Link: 5 Best Apps for Babies: Fuel their Curiosity









What to read next

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Consequat aliquet tellus suspendisse semper. Pulvinar semper porta tortor venenatis dictum. Neque et non tincidunt turpis mauris aliquet nunc aliquam volutpat.

Baby Box Subscription

Monthly subscription box for babies aged 0-3 years - delivering unique, fun products

star star star star star
(5.0 rating)
take baby quiz